Navigating Sustainability: Pros & Cons of Clean Fleet Technologies



A red and green graphic with the words "Pros & Cons: Sustainable Fleet Futures and Clean Technology".

The future will see a mix of clean technologies suited to different needs and applications. Understanding these options and considering the unique factors of your fleet is crucial.


As fleet managers across the U.S. increasingly prioritize sustainability, the conversation is no longer about if we should adopt cleaner solutions but how.

According to a recent Shell Fleet Solutions survey, 65% of fleet managers list sustainability as a top priority. However, achieving sustainable fleet operations can feel like navigating a labyrinth of options, regulations, and emerging technologies.

We’re entering a “peak complexity” period, where the transition to greener fleets is compounded by new emissions standards and evolving state and federal regulations. The good news is that fleet managers have many options to make their operations more environmentally friendly.

The key is to avoid getting siloed into a single technology. The future will see a mix of clean technologies suited to different needs and applications. Understanding these options and considering the unique factors of your fleet is crucial.

Factors to Consider in Fleet Sustainability

When evaluating sustainability options for your fleet, it’s essential to take a holistic view, looking at factors such as:

  • Vehicle mileage: High-mileage vehicles may require different fuel technologies than lower-mileage ones.
  • Fleet age: Older vehicles may be less adaptable to new technologies without significant retrofitting.
  • Vehicle usage: Is your fleet transporting goods, performing road repairs, or functioning as energy vehicles? Each application demands different energy solutions.
  • Fleet size/vehicle turnover: Larger fleets with frequent turnover may benefit more from investing in long-term clean solutions than smaller, stable fleets.
  • Costs: Upfront and operational costs vary across clean technologies, and cost-benefit analyses should guide decisions.

Exploring Your Clean Technology Options

Fleet managers now have multiple clean technology options at their disposal. Here are the key contenders:

  • Renewable Natural Gas (RNG):
    • Pros: RNG is a cleaner alternative to fossil fuels, utilizing organic waste to produce energy. It reduces lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions and can be used in existing natural gas vehicles.
    • Cons: While RNG reduces emissions, its availability and infrastructure remain limited in certain regions.
  • Hydrogen:
    • Pros: Hydrogen fuel offers zero emissions and quick refueling times.
    • Cons: Infrastructure is still developing, and the production process must become greener to realize its full potential.
  • Zero Emission Vehicles (FCEV/BEV):
    • Pros: Battery-electric and fuel-cell electric vehicles are emission-free at the point of use, ideal for short-haul and urban operations.
    • Cons: High upfront costs, range limitations for BEVs, and charging/refueling infrastructure still need to be improved for widespread adoption.
  • Biofuels:
    • Pros: An emerging option, biofuels offer a renewable energy source and can work with existing diesel engines.
    • Cons: While promising, biofuels are still under study, and scalability is questioned.
    • What I think: Biofuels will be part of the industry’s future, especially as research and development progress.

Integration vs. Building Something New

When moving to sustainable fleets, fleet managers can integrate clean technologies into their existing operations or invest in entirely new vehicles built with sustainability in mind.

Integration may be more cost-effective for fleets looking to retrofit while building something new, which offers the potential for long-term savings and greater environmental impact.

The Road Ahead: Uncertainty and Opportunity

With new legislation on the horizon, uncertainty looms over the fleet industry. What is certain, however, is that sustainability is the future of commercial transport. Ecomobility is not a trend; it’s the direction we’re moving as an industry. The time to evaluate your options is now.

At Landi Technologies, we’re committed to helping fleet managers navigate these complexities. Whether you’re looking to integrate clean technology into your existing fleet or start fresh with the latest sustainable solutions, we can guide you through the process and ensure you make the right choice for your business and the environment.

About the Author: Andrea Landi is president of Landi Technologies, a leading U.S. manufacturer of innovative technologies for eco-friendly commercial vehicles based in Torrance, CA. Their mission is to empower the transition to sustainable transportation by delivering cutting-edge technologies that reduce emissions, enhance efficiency, and drive business success.

This article was authored and edited according to Automotive Fleet’s editorial standards and style. Opinions expressed may not reflect that of Automotive Fleet.



Source link

About The Author

Scroll to Top